The Heimlich maneuver is one of the most widely recognized first aid techniques for relieving airway obstructions caused by choking. This life-saving intervention is designed to dislodge foreign or small objects, that block the airway, restoring the individual’s ability to breathe. While the Heimlich maneuver is highly effective when used correctly, there are specific situations where performing it may not be appropriate or could even cause harm.
This comprehensive guide explores the circumstances under which the Heimlich maneuver should not be performed, alternative actions to take in those situations, and essential considerations for safely managing choking emergencies.
Understanding the Heimlich Maneuver
Before discussing when to avoid the Heimlich maneuver, it is important to understand its purpose and how it works.
-
Purpose: The Heimlich maneuver, also known as the abdominal thrust, applies pressure to the abdomen, forcing air from the lungs to create an artificial cough. This action can expel a foreign object blocking the airway.
-
Appropriate Use: The Heimlich maneuver is most effective for adults and children over one year old who are choking due to a complete airway obstruction and are unable to cough, speak, or breathe.
Assessing the Situation
Before administering the Heimlich maneuver, assess the situation carefully to ensure that the person choking requires immediate intervention and that it is safe to proceed.
Signs of Complete Airway Obstruction
-
The individual cannot speak or make sounds.
-
There is no airflow in or out of the lungs.
-
The person clutches their throat (a universal choking sign).
-
Skin may turn blue due to lack of oxygen (cyanosis).
Signs of Partial Airway Obstruction
-
The individual can cough forcefully, speak, or breathe, albeit with difficulty.
-
There may be wheezing or high-pitched sounds during breathing.
If the person has a partial airway obstruction, the Heimlich maneuver is unnecessary and could worsen the situation. Encourage them to continue coughing to expel the object naturally while monitoring their condition.
When to Avoid the Heimlich Maneuver
1. Infants Under One Year Old
Infants have delicate anatomy, and the force used in abdominal thrusts can cause severe internal injuries.
-
Alternative Action: For choking infants, use a combination of back blows and chest thrusts:
-
Place the infant face-down on your forearm, supporting their head and neck.
-
Deliver five firm back blows between the shoulder blades.
-
Turn the infant face-up and use two fingers to deliver five gentle chest thrusts. Repeat as necessary.
-
2. Pregnant Individuals
Performing abdominal thrusts on a pregnant woman could harm the fetus and cause injury to the mother.
-
Alternative Action: Modify the Heimlich maneuver by performing chest thrusts instead of abdominal thrusts:
-
Place your hands on the center of the chest, just above the baby bump.
-
Deliver quick, inward and upward thrusts to expel the obstruction.
-
3. Frail or Elderly Individuals
Older adults are more susceptible to injuries such as broken ribs or internal damage due to weakened bones and tissues. When delivering back blows, use the heel of your hand to strike between the victim's shoulder blades to help dislodge the obstruction.
-
Alternative Action: Use chest thrusts instead of abdominal thrusts if you suspect that standard techniques could cause harm.
-
Considerations: Be gentle and assess their physical condition before proceeding.
4. Individuals with Partial Airway Obstruction
When a person can still cough, breathe, or speak, they are experiencing a partial airway obstruction. The Heimlich maneuver is unnecessary in this case.
-
Recommended Action:
-
Encourage them to keep coughing to clear the obstruction naturally.
-
Monitor their condition to ensure the situation does not worsen.
-
5. Non-Foreign Object Airway Obstructions
The Heimlich maneuver is ineffective against airway blockages caused by factors other than solid objects.
Examples of Non-Foreign Object Obstructions:
-
Allergic Reactions (Anaphylaxis): Swelling in the airway can obstruct breathing.
-
Action: Administer an epinephrine auto-injector (e.g., EpiPen) if available and call emergency services immediately.
-
-
Fluid Obstruction: Vomit, saliva, or blood may block the airway, especially in unconscious individuals.
-
Action: Turn the person onto their side to allow fluids to drain and prevent aspiration.
-
-
Swelling from Burns or Infections: Swelling due to thermal injuries or infections can narrow the airway.
-
Action: Seek immediate medical attention and provide supportive care, such as keeping the airway open.
-
6. Unconscious Individuals
The Heimlich maneuver is designed for conscious individuals. If the person becomes unresponsive while choking, transition to CPR.
-
Recommended Action:
-
Check for a pulse and breathing.
-
Begin CPR if necessary, with chest compressions and rescue breaths.
-
Check the airway for visible obstructions between compressions and remove them if possible.
-
Special Considerations for a Choking Person
When dealing with a choking person, it’s essential to consider their specific needs and circumstances to ensure the safest and most effective intervention. For instance, if the person is pregnant, performing abdominal thrusts could harm both the mother and the baby. Instead, use chest thrusts by placing your hands on the center of the chest, just above the baby bump, and delivering quick, inward and upward thrusts.
Similarly, if the person is obese, the standard Heimlich maneuver may not be effective. In this case, place your hands slightly higher on their torso, just under the breastbone, to accommodate their larger body. This adjustment helps create the necessary pressure to expel the foreign object.
For infants and toddlers, the approach differs significantly. For babies under one year old, avoid abdominal thrusts altogether. Instead, use a combination of back blows and chest thrusts. Place the infant face-down on your forearm, supporting their head and neck, and deliver five firm back blows between the shoulder blades. Then, turn the infant face-up and use two fingers to deliver five gentle chest thrusts. For toddlers, use less forceful thrusts to avoid injury.
If the person becomes unconscious, do not perform the Heimlich maneuver. Instead, start CPR immediately and call for emergency medical help. This approach ensures that you provide the most appropriate care based on the individual’s condition and needs.
Responding to Choking Emergencies
Effectively managing a choking emergency requires a step-by-step approach:
Step 1: Assess the Severity
-
Determine if the airway is partially or fully blocked.
-
Observe whether the person can cough, speak, or breathe.
Step 2: Encourage Coughing (If Partial Obstruction)
-
Allow the person to continue coughing if they can do so effectively.
-
Reassure them and stay nearby to monitor their condition.
Step 3: Perform Abdominal Thrusts (If Fully Obstructed)
-
For adults, pregnant women, and children over one year old, perform abdominal thrusts.
-
Stand behind the person, wrap your arms around their waist, and place a fist just above their navel.
-
Deliver quick, inward and upward thrusts until the object is expelled or the person becomes unconscious.
Step 4: Call for Help
-
If the obstruction does not clear, or the person’s condition worsens, call emergency services immediately.
Performing the Heimlich Maneuver on Yourself
If you find yourself alone and choking, you can still perform the Heimlich maneuver on yourself to try and dislodge the obstruction. Here’s how you can do it:
-
Stand in front of a stable object, such as a chair or table.
-
Place your hands on the object to steady yourself.
-
Lean forward and thrust your upper abdominal area against the edge of the object.
-
Repeat the thrusts until the foreign object is expelled.
Alternatively, you can perform abdominal thrusts on yourself. Make a fist and place your thumb below your rib cage and above your navel. Grasp your fist with your other hand and press it into your upper abdomen, with a quick, upward movement. This self-administered technique can help create the necessary pressure to clear your airway.
Remember, in a choking emergency, every second counts. Act quickly and seek medical attention immediately if you’re unable to dislodge the object on your own. Your prompt action can make all the difference in a life-threatening situation.
Personal Safety Considerations
When providing first aid, prioritize your safety as well as the choking individual’s.
-
Avoid Physical Risks: Ensure the environment is safe before intervening.
-
Manage Panic: Stay calm to reassure the choking individual and prevent further distress.
Training and Preparation
Comprehensive first aid training equips individuals with the knowledge and confidence to handle choking emergencies effectively.
Benefits of Training:
-
Learn proper techniques for the Heimlich maneuver, CPR, and alternative actions.
-
Understand how to assess airway obstructions and respond appropriately.
-
Gain insight into specific considerations for infants, pregnant individuals, and the elderly.
Resources:
-
Online first aid courses from organizations like MyCPR NOW or local health agencies.
-
Practice sessions using manikins to develop muscle memory and refine techniques.
Summary
The Heimlich maneuver is a powerful tool for addressing choking emergencies, but its application requires careful consideration. Using the technique in inappropriate situations can cause harm or fail to resolve the obstruction.
By understanding when not to perform the Heimlich maneuver and being prepared with alternative responses, you can handle choking emergencies confidently and compassionately. Comprehensive training ensures that you can make informed decisions, potentially saving lives while minimizing risks. A prepared responder is an effective responder.
